Really? Opening with a symphonic and chorale arrangement, it’s not until ‘Nobody Leaves’ that any metallic elements are evident: ultra quick (ala Rhapsody or early Sonata Arctica), but with heavier drumming and staccato riffing. Can’t shake the classical influence though, it reoccurs throughout the remaining nine songs, including a backing choir on the title cut. Some have made allusions to Blind Guardian, but other than nationality and the odd a cappella vocal (‘Welcome Liberty’), not an accurate assessment. The strongest impression comes courtesy of ‘All These Dark Years’, which utilizes a bit of female backing. A lone piano introduces ‘Nothing Remains’, which eventually gets the guitars revving, while ‘Requiem’ has predominately pizzicato harp strings, synth and the occasional, unaccompanied vocal. ‘We Are Pirates’ varies from a beginning trot to full gallop come midsection, only bringing the concertina out for the final verse. Things get a little busy during the lengthy (8:51) ‘Of Downfall And Decline’ finale, taking a kitchen sink approach to songwriting with heaviness, acoustic guitars, gang vocals, etc.
A good album, even if it doesn’t live up to the hype.